Grill type · Explainer
Charcoal Grills: Smoky Flavor, Higher Skill Ceiling
Charcoal grills produce the strongest grill flavor and reach the highest sear temperatures of any common backyard cooker. They reward patience.
Grills.co Editorial · Updated January 14, 2026
Best for
- • Smoky flavor
- • High-heat searing
- • Weekend cooks who enjoy ritual
Pros
- +Strong smoky flavor
- +Capable of very high searing temperatures
- +Simple mechanical design
- +Inexpensive fuel
Cons
- −Slower to start than gas
- −Temperature control requires practice
- −Ash cleanup
- −Less convenient on weeknights
What charcoal grills are
Charcoal grills use lump charcoal or briquettes as the heat source. Airflow through bottom vents and top exhausts controls combustion rate, which sets the cooking temperature. The cook is responsible for managing fuel distribution, airflow, and timing.
How a charcoal grill cooks
Two-zone setup is the foundational technique: pile coals on one side, leave the other side empty. Sear over coals, then move to the empty side to finish gently. With a lid down and vents partly closed, a charcoal grill becomes a real smoker.
Charcoal also reaches the highest sear temperatures of any common backyard cooker. With a hot bed of lump charcoal, you can hit 700–900°F at the grate.
What to look for
- Four-vent design (bottom and top, multiple positions).
- Hinged grate for refueling mid-cook.
- Ash management — a sweeper or removable ash pan.
- Lid thermometer with reasonable accuracy.
- Charcoal grate quality — thin charcoal grates warp and dump coals.
Maintenance
Empty ash after every cook. Brush cooking grates while hot. Once a season, remove the grate, dump remaining ash, wipe out the bowl, and inspect vents for ash buildup.
Notable charcoal grills
PK Grills PK Original
Best for: Two-zone charcoal cooks
The PK Original is the cult favorite charcoal grill for cooks who want true two-zone control. The cast aluminum body lasts decades.
Affiliate link · Amazon
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to light a charcoal grill?
About 15–20 minutes with a chimney starter. Lighter fluid is faster but contributes off-flavors and is unnecessary once you own a chimney.
Lump charcoal vs briquettes?
Briquettes burn longer at a more consistent temperature — good for beginners and long indirect cooks. Lump burns hotter and produces less ash — good for searing and for kamados.